HomeNew London CountyEast Lyme
New London County · RealTrends Top Agent 2022–2026 · CB President's Elite 2022–2026

Real Estate Agent in East Lyme, CT — Nick Tomanelli.

Niantic's shoreline charm, Pattagansett Lake, and a growing market where shoreline access meets year-round livability.

Market Overview

Real estate in East Lyme, Connecticut.

East Lyme encompasses the shoreline village of Niantic — one of southeastern Connecticut's most beloved small waterfront communities — as well as the broader town of East Lyme with its lakefront Pattagansett area and established residential neighborhoods. Niantic's Main Street, directly on the water with beach access and a walkable commercial district, has driven a steady appreciation in demand from buyers seeking the Connecticut shoreline experience without the premium of Westport or Madison. The town is increasingly a year-round community rather than a seasonal one, as buyers discover its combination of shoreline access, strong schools, and practical Route 1 and I-95 connectivity.

5xRealTrends Top Agent, 2022–2026
5xCB President's Elite, 2022–2026
CTStatewide License #0816258
Market Snapshot

What to know about the East Lyme market.

East Lyme's market centers on the $350K–$650K range for single-family homes, with waterfront and near-water Niantic properties carrying significant premiums above $700K. The Niantic beach area is the most competitive submarket — inventory there is extremely limited and well-priced properties attract motivated buyers quickly. The broader residential town is more accessible and offers solid value relative to the shoreline towns to the west. Second-home buyers are a consistent presence, particularly in the beach neighborhoods.

01

For Buyers

East Lyme buyers are often deciding between primary-home and second-home use — and the Niantic area serves both well. I help buyers understand the flood zone considerations for shoreline properties, the practical difference between beach-area and inland East Lyme, and what realistic competition looks like for the specific properties they're targeting.

02

For Sellers

Selling in East Lyme, particularly in Niantic, means reaching buyers from across southern New England and beyond — the town's shoreline character attracts buyers from Hartford, New Haven, Rhode Island, and the New York metro. Marketing that reaches that audience and captures the property's water access and village character drives the best results.

Common Questions

Frequently asked about East Lyme real estate

What is the real estate market like in East Lyme (Niantic), CT?

East Lyme is a growing shoreline market with single-family prices typically running $350K–$650K. The Niantic beach area commands premium pricing and has very limited inventory; well-priced shoreline properties sell quickly. The town attracts both primary and second-home buyers from across the region.

Is Niantic, CT a good place to buy a beach home?

Niantic is one of southeastern Connecticut's most desirable shoreline communities — a genuine walkable beach village with a waterfront Main Street, beach access, and a year-round residential character. Demand consistently exceeds supply in the beach neighborhood.

Does Nick Tomanelli help buyers and sellers in East Lyme, CT?

Yes. Nick works across East Lyme and Niantic — with primary-home buyers, second-home buyers, and sellers of shoreline and inland properties. He provides full-service representation and data-driven pricing.

Get in Touch

Ready to talk about your plans in East Lyme?

Your information is kept strictly confidential.

© 2026 Nick Tomanelli. All rights reserved.
Coldwell Banker Realty is a registered trademark licensed to Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC.